Listed below are the liens/RIDs that were found at the PDS/PSA February 2016 review of the Prelanding thru Escort 1 phases of the Rosetta mission. Even though this particular data set may have not participated in the review, it uses the same pipeline and so the liens likely apply here as well. Please take note that some issues may be resolved, while others are not. If any other issues are discovered please let the PDS-SBN know. It is expected that a fully lien resolved version will be produced during post mission ops and archived with an incremented data set version number. 1)Reference Id(RID): RO-AR-RID-RPCLAP-100-YK Dataset: all Location: - Title: No derived data Description: No derived data archive is available. So the general usability of the archive is limited to expert users. Proposed solution by Reviewer: Provide DERIVED data archive Review board discussion outcome and Instrument team response: The team plan to provide derived data. 2)Reference Id(RID): RO-AR-RID-RPCLAP-101-YK Dataset: all Location: - Title: Provide files covering longer time intervals Description: Currently the archive consists of zilions of 2-3 kB text files. A modern disk drive has a block size of 128 kB, so approximately 98% of disk space is wasted. Moreover, a science user would typically want to analyze a longer sequence of data representing a particular kind of measurement, from tens of minutes to several days, and combing data from numerous small files is very cumbersiome. Therefore it would be very useful if the instrument team provides files covering more manageble time intervals, e.g. daily files. Proposed solution by Reviewer: Provide daily files Review board discussion outcome and Instrument team response: the derived data will cover longer time intervals 3)Reference Id(RID): RO-AR-RID-RPCLAP-102-YK Dataset: geometry Location: - Title: Duplicated geometry data Description: Geometry data provided in both the edited and calibrated archives. Proposed solution by Reviewer: Provide only one version of geometry data, possibly even a reference to a mission level geometry dataset. Review board discussion outcome and Instrument team response: The reviewer would like a more general information common to all instruments and information will be provided within the derived data. 4)Reference Id(RID): RO-AR-RID-RPCLAP-103-YK Dataset: all Location: ICD, RO-C-RPCLAP-3-PRL-CALIB-V1.0_v2015-08-28update/DATASET.CAT Title: Provide better description of data products Description: Currently the information about the science data products (section 2.9.2) is scattered over the entire ICD. Also some info can be found in DATASET.CAT. It would be very useful for the science user to have this information assempled in one section and ordered by the data product. is section 2.9.2 is extended to include descriptive text about each of the science products, their calibration details and a caveats section. Proposed solution by Reviewer: Extended section 2.9.2 of the ICD to include descriptive text about each of the science products, their calibration details and a caveats section. Review board discussion outcome and Instrument team response: The team agree to look into the documentation. 5)Reference Id(RID): RO-AR-RID-RPCLAP-104-YK Dataset: - Location: ICD, Ch 2.5, Ch 2.6, Ch 2.7 Title: remove "not of interest" Description: Several sections start with a note that the following section is not of interest for most of science users, while the following section would normally contain very valuable information. Therefore the leadin note must be removed. Proposed solution by Reviewer: remove "not of interest" Review board discussion outcome and Instrument team response: - 6)Reference Id(RID): RO-AR-RID-RPCLAP-105-YK Dataset: - Location: ICD, Ch 2.5, 3rd paragraph Title: List information about saturation in a Caveats section Description: Information about saturation is very important for interpretation of data. Proposed solution by Reviewer: List information about saturation in a Caveats section Review board discussion outcome and Instrument team response: - 7)Reference Id(RID): RO-AR-RID-RPCLAP-106-YK Dataset: - Location: ICD, Ch 2.5, 4th paragraph Title: List information about bias timing in a Caveats section Description: Information about instrument responce to bias changes is very important for interpretation of data. Proposed solution by Reviewer: List information about bias timing in a Caveats section Review board discussion outcome and Instrument team response: - 8)Reference Id(RID): RO-AR-RID-RPCLAP-107-YK Dataset: - Location: ICD, Ch 2.5, last paragrapth Title: List information about bias in section 2.9.2 Description: Information that the bias values given in the files are not measured is important for interpretation of data and need to be provided in description of relevant products in section 2.9.2. Proposed solution by Reviewer: List information about bias in section 2.9.2 Review board discussion outcome and Instrument team response: - 9)Reference Id(RID): RO-AR-RID-RPCLAP-108-YK Dataset: - Location: ICD, Ch 2.6, 2nd paragrapth Title: clarify "we" Description: "WE" need to be replaced by an appropriate intitution name in sentence starting with "We run the software..". Proposed solution by Reviewer: clarify "we" Review board discussion outcome and Instrument team response: - 10)Reference Id(RID): RO-AR-RID-RPCLAP-109-YK Dataset: - Loaction: ICD, Ch 2.7, 2nd paragrapth Title: provide details on gemetry data Description: Describe how the geomerty data is produced and using which inputs Proposed solution by Reviewer: provide details on gemetry data Review board discussion outcome and Instrument team response: - 11)Reference Id(RID): RO-AR-RID-RPCLAP-110-YK Dataset: - Loaction: ICD, Ch 2.9.1 Title: Provide information about transfer function in section 2.9.2 Description: Information that the transfer function are not being used but are available is important for interpretation of data and need to be provided in description of relevant products in section 2.9.2. Proposed solution by Reviewer: Provide information about transfer function in section 2.9.2 Review board discussion outcome and Instrument team response: - 12)Reference Id(RID): RO-AR-RID-RPCLAP-111-YK Dataset: - Loaction: ICD, Ch 2.9.2 Title: Provide information about HK parameters Description: List the contents of the 27 parameters contained in the housekeeping file (table in sec 2.9.2). Proposed solution by Reviewer: Provide information about HK parameters Review board discussion outcome and Instrument team response: - 13)Reference Id(RID): RO-AR-RID-RPCLAP-101-SPJ Dataset: "ro-c-rpclap-2-esc1-edited-v1.0, ro-c-rpclap-2-prl-edited-v1.0, ro-c-rpclap-3-esc1-calib-v1.0, ro-c-rpclap-3-prl-calib-v1.0" Location: data directories Title: data format is not usable Description: time series data are so fragmented as to be effectively unusable. A single day is framented into more than 7000 files with durations from a few seconds to a few minutes Proposed solution by Reviewer: There must be some way to group the files into usable granules. The data provider is asked to explore alternative directory structures (to store similar files) or file structures (to combine the contents of several files) Review board discussion outcome and Instrument team response: repeat of European reviewer's comments.derived level data sets, still to be delivered, will include both the derived properties and longer time-series; ESA exploring contract to modify 14)Reference Id(RID): RO-AR-RID-RPCLAP-102-SPJ Dataset: "ro-c-rpclap-2-esc1-edited-v1.0, ro-c-rpclap-2-prl-edited-v1.0, ro-c-rpclap-3-esc1-calib-v1.0, ro-c-rpclap-3-prl-calib-v1.0" Location: data directories Title: document ways to reformat and/or combine data to improve usability Description: time series data are so fragmented as to be effectively unusable. A single day is framented into more than 7000 files with durations from a few seconds to a few minutes Proposed solution by Reviewer: The data provider is asked to document ways to combine/reconsitute the data files into more manageable forms Review board discussion outcome and Instrument team response: repeat of European reviewer's comments.derived level data sets, still to be delivered, will include both the derived properties and longer time-series; ESA exploring contract to modify 15)Reference Id(RID): RO-AR-RID-RPCLAP-101-MB Dataset: ALL Location: ALL Title: Technical PSA RIDs Description: Please correct all PSA RIDs. Word Document provided to the team Proposed solution by Reviewer: - Review board discussion outcome and Instrument team response: - 16)Reference Id(RID): RO-AR-RID-RPCLAP-101-SBN Dataset: ALL Location: ALL Title: Techincal PDS RIDS Description: Please correct all PDS RIDs. Proposed solution by Reviewer: - Review board discussion outcome and Instrument team response: - 17)Reference Id(RID): ro-c-rpclap-101-RE Dataset: ro-c-rpclap-3-prl-calib-v1.0 Location: calib/rpclap*frq*.txt Title: avoid using OBJECT = TEXT? Description: "Is it possible/feasible to convert each to a spreadsheet or a fixed-width table, instead of having the .lbl treat it as a lump of text with no column definitions?" Proposed solution by Reviewer: consider Review board discussion outcome and Instrument team response: - 18)Reference Id(RID): ro-c-rpclap-102-RE Dataset: ro-c-rpclap-3-prl-calib-v1.0 Location: document/ro-irfu-lap-eaicd-1_9_2.pdf Title: RPCLAP PDF Description: "sec 3.1.2: for TARGET_ID, list ""C"" as the value for comet - sec 3.1.4: the table is hard to read. Maybe make it a true table with a border and 3 columns: code, meaning, values - sec 3.4.3.5: the row for the EAICD mentions a .DOC version, which was not in the volume or pointed to by the .lbl, i.e. probably don't mention the .DOC - sec 4.3.1.5: alphabetize the table. - sec 4.3.1.5: the table has ""LAP_P1_E-FIELD_FIX_DURATION"" and ""LAP_P2_E-FIELD_FIX_DURATION"", but the corresponding keywords in the labels have no '-', and nowhere else does the table use '-' - sec 4.3.1.5: The following keywords were not found in ro-c-rpclap-3-prl-calib-v1.0, though perhaps others will: LAP_P1_ADC16_UNI_BI_POLAR LAP_P2_ADC16_UNI_BI_POLAR LAP_LDL_ACTIVE LAP_LDL_MODE LAP_P2_ADC16_DIG_FILT_CUTOFF LAP_P1_ADC16_DIG_FILT_CUTOFF LAP_P2_ADC16_DIG_FILT_STATUS LAP_P1_ADC16_DIG_FILT_STATUS LAP_P1P2_ADC20_RECORD_LENGTH LAP_TRANSMITTER_FREQUENCY LAP_TRANSMITTER_AMPLITUDE LAP_TRANSMITTER_STATUS" Proposed solution by Reviewer: see description Review board discussion outcome and Instrument team response: -